Since all instant start electronic ballast with 4 wire (Used only for the lamp filament fusing mechanism at lamp EOL), operates at exactly the same manner of simply applying HV on the cold cathodes to start the lamp, variations in lamp life on different instant start electronic ballasts aren't related to the starting mothed, but to other reasons:
1. The electrodes that are used in the lamp: Triple coil electrodes that can withstand cold starting better than the usual double and single coil electrodes, because this electrode shape, is actually a compromise between the filament style electrodes of the fluorescent lamps, and the beehive style electrodes of LPS lamps, that can withstand cold starting much better, so thats why LPS lamps usually have longer life than fluorescent lamps in one start per day.
2. The wattage that the ballast operates the lamp. If the lamp is underdriven, so the lamp will actually operate with cold cathodes, resulting in a heavy sputtering. If the lamp operates at full wattage, the sputtering will be low. If the lamp is overdriven, then the overloading on the electronic will cause heavy sputtering.
I bought my Hyundai Teva generic CFL that I have,
at 25.4.2010 , and is still operational after almost 3 years, despite frequently switching, partially because it have triple coil electrodes, and also because it is operating in my table lamp base up, so the heat from the tube, don't heats the ballast, and keeps it cool, so the ballast don't overheats.
On the other hand, the 8W T5 lamps on the 2 lamps electronic instant start fixture, in my mother bathroom, burns out every several months. Beside frequent switching, the electrodes aren't suitable for cold starting, and also: I suspecting that the ballast underdrives the lamps.