Author Topic: Why Free Will May Be a Necessary Illusion  (Read 154 times)
Omnilight37
Member
**
Offline

Gender: Male
View Posts
View Gallery

Keep Shining


Why Free Will May Be a Necessary Illusion « on: November 21, 2026, 07:16:02 PM » Author: Omnilight37
 Before We Begin: If you're reading this, please don't stop. I want you to sit down, listen, and understand me. Over the last couple of months, I've been feeling really powerless and distraught in my personal life due to a scientific and philosophical debate that is tearing me apart—free will. In August of this year, I posted the topic Does Anybody Else Feel Powerless in Their Lives?, where Patrick and I had a very insightful conversation together. We talked about free will, the criminal justice system, and randomness in quantum physics. While that was wonderful, I still do not feel that posting a single time about the debate between determinism and free will, and the personal toll it has had on me, was enough to convey the full extent of my anguish. If you're not up to speed on that, please read the post linked above.

 Before we get into my emotional distress over this debate, we need to cover some science. Over the last couple of months, I have been researching why the belief in free will is so widespread among humanity in the first place. It seems like quite the paradox to me: most humans believe that everything has a cause and effect. You throw a rock into a lake, and you get a splash; you flip a switch, and you get light. However, we humans seem to have a blind spot when applying those same logical principles to our own brains. Instead, we believe we possess some sort of free will that makes our neural processes exempt from pure causality. After extensive research, I can now strongly conclude that this belief is a byproduct of evolution. After reading this article, Understanding Free Will as a Biological Phenomenon, by Bjørn Grinde, a retired evolutionary biologist from the Norwegian Institute of Public Health who researched human behavior and evolution, I am strongly convinced that our belief in free will, and why we perceive it as exempt from causality, are byproducts of evolution. Additionally, after reading the research paper The Influence of (Dis)belief in Free Will on Immoral Behavior, I am very persuaded that our level of belief in free will has measurable effects on our thoughts, beliefs, and actions.

 The belief in free will may be a necessary illusion, as a strong sense of personal agency has already been established to bolster mood, productivity, and a higher sense of morale. Even though free will itself may be completely nonexistent, the belief in it may be key to sustaining human society. If, all of a sudden, everybody genuinely stopped believing in free will, then I surmise that a lack of responsibility for one's actions would lead society into chaos. People would stop taking moral accountability because they no longer believed they had a choice, and this would be a very dire situation. As Patrick once said, even if free will isn't true, that doesn't necessarily mean we need a total overhaul of our system of justice and our notion of accountability.

 Now that we have wrapped up the science, it is time to focus on the deep and damaging personal effect this has had on me. I have felt completely powerless in my life after reading the studies. I have tried to cope by trying to see if there were any alternative research papers that could've disproved this notion, but none of them seem viable. I have constant stress, I can't get out of bed, and I feel completely trapped. I have considered ending it all, but after careful consideration, I find the outcome to be quite selfish. If I end my life, I am free. However, what about my family? The cost of me being free is that it would completely shatter the lives of the few people who care about me, leaving them in grief. I can't bring myself to do it. I know what grief is, and I have seen what it has done to people. I can't accept any outcome where my family has to endure anything like that. As much as I want to escape this deterministic suffering, I can't do that to my family. I go about my daily life, and I feel as if nobody understands me. I find it difficult to connect with people, and the only people who seem to understand me are some of you. I don't know any of you, I don't even know what most of you look like, and none of you know my name, my face, or the person behind the name Omnilight37. However, I have felt a deep intellectual connection to some of you. This has occurred primarily through a mutual passion for street lights and also a deep sense of intellectual relatability. Could one call this an artificial connection? Perhaps. After all, I'm just some random, faceless guy on a niche forum whom you met. It may be artificial, but it is now what gets me through my life. I love seeing you guys love street lights like I do, talk about bulbs, and get excited about what I also love to do. In my personal life, my family and so-called friends just brush it off or get bored. They don't want to talk about street lights, bulbs, or philosophy at all; they think it's an unhealthy obsession.

 That's enough of the negativity. I know it may be very hard to read. I would like to point out that there is still profound good in life, and everybody needs balance. As I go about my day, I'm excited by the little things. I may be the #1 biggest fan of the AEL LuxMaster Series on this forum, and I'm overjoyed whenever I see one. Last month, I wrote a post about the "history" of the AEL LuxMaster Series, and that was really well received. Additionally, I love good food, and even a small burger will take me from feeling irate to feeling great. As much negativity as there is in this world, there are also many positive aspects that balance it. I have the will to survive, and like a Holophane HMAO LED III, I will pierce my light through whatever storm may get in my way.

Keep Shining,

-Omnilight37

 
Logged

*Getting Brighter by the Day!*

I'm an avid lighting enthusiast who works with and studies ballasts, ignitors and lighting optics while identifying various models and manufacturers of electric lighting. I am actively studying particle physics and seek to understand the mechanics of a photon.

SoxFtw
Member
***
Offline

Gender: Male
View Posts
View Gallery

"If it's stupid and it works, it ain't stupid."


My Thoughts: Why Free Will May Be a Necessary Illusion « Reply #1 on: Today at 01:58:01 AM » Author: SoxFtw
I know little about the matter but I shall try to express my thoughts as best I can.

Let's take your example: You throw a rock into a lake, and you get a splash. But to what extent are you throwing the rock with your own will? Perhaps your brain saw it and decided to, by means of your hand, throw it into the lake. So does your hand really have the "free will" to choose not to throw the rock, and how much of it was it even your choice and not something randomly decided by a set of chemical signals?
The same goes with impulse reactions. Picture this scenario: A fast-moving object (a housefly, for example) nears your face, you flinch, and knock over a glass of water. Was it actually your choice to knock over the glass or was it merely a coincidence out of your control; a byproduct of an action of which you had no control over in the first place?
I personally would like to believe that, to a certain extent, we have free will; in that I too fall into part of your observation—a lack of perceived free will can be detrimental to one's morale.

Now that we have wrapped up the science, it is time to focus on the deep and damaging personal effect this has had on me. I have felt completely powerless in my life after reading the studies. I have tried to cope by trying to see if there were any alternative research papers that could've disproved this notion, but none of them seem viable. I have constant stress, I can't get out of bed, and I feel completely trapped. (1.) I have considered ending it all, but after careful consideration, I find the outcome to be quite selfish. If I end my life, I am free. However, what about my family? The cost of me being free is that it would completely shatter the lives of the few people who care about me, leaving them in grief. I can't bring myself to do it. I know what grief is, and I have seen what it has done to people. (2.) I can't accept any outcome where my family has to endure anything like that. As much as I want to escape this deterministic suffering, I can't do that to my family. I go about my daily life, and I feel as if nobody understands me. I find it difficult to connect with people, and the only people who seem to understand me are some of you. I don't know any of you, I don't even know what most of you look like, and none of you know my name, my face, or the person behind the name Omnilight37. However, I have felt a deep intellectual connection to some of you. This has occurred primarily through a mutual passion for street lights and also a deep sense of intellectual relatability. Could one call this an artificial connection? Perhaps. After all, (3.) I'm just some random, faceless guy on a niche forum whom you met. It may be artificial, but it is now what gets me through my life. I love seeing you guys love street lights like I do, talk about bulbs, and get excited about what I also love to do. In my personal life, my family and so-called friends just brush it off or get bored. They don't want to talk about street lights, bulbs, or philosophy at all; they think it's an unhealthy obsession.

I will disagree a bit with you here, in the portions I have highlighted:

1. Take this, by no means, as my endorsement of yours—or anyone's—death, but I want you to ask yourself, is suicide really "selfish" in the manner you describe it to be? Death is inevitable, which we know to be true as an objective fact, and is something we only have partial free will over. The free will in this matter is to either let nature take its course (which is unpredictable) or attempt to change the timeline yourself, which too, has an unpredictable outcome. Is it really selfish to attempt to rearrange the timeline of your death which was bound to happen regardless of your actions, knowing of the consequences which will likely remain the same throughout?

2. This is bound to happen, regardless of your choices. The only thing you can change is your knowledge about how it will happen, and no more. And that too cannot be predicted with 100% certainty, as is with most things in life.

3. A person does not need to know you, in order to have a "connection" with you. Isn't this the exact same story with 99% of members here, who all started off as unknown people on a niche forum? Someone who has a passion in collecting lamps is no different from one who collects, for example, coins. To you it may appear as just some pieces of metal you can use to pay for stuff; in the same way they view every light bulb as "just a source of light". This does not mean it's an "unhealthy obsession", unless it's affecting your life in a manner you cannot control. You do not need to justify your interests to anyone—you owe the world nothing.

Free will may or may not exist, but that doesn't mean we can't appreciate the things we have in life. Even if we cannot control every aspect of our existence, that doesn't mean we can't feel genuine enjoyment from said aspects. Your actions do not necessarily have to be the products of free will to matter. People genuinely care about you, and by that I mean you, not just the alias Omnilight37.

<edit by me>
some phrasing and grammar edits, and no it's not just AI that uses emdashes
</edit>
« Last Edit: Today at 03:01:30 PM by SoxFtw » Logged

Survivor of photokeratitis :(
👉KeepAndroidOpen.org👈

RCM442
Administrator
Member
*****
Offline

Gender: Male
View Posts
View Gallery

rcm442 UC1Q-wYhi9O-1q4ugOaOZ9dA rcm442
WWW
Re: Why Free Will May Be a Necessary Illusion « Reply #2 on: Today at 12:53:48 PM » Author: RCM442
Suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem. I know it may be harder for you but I always try and be positive even when my life has been bad.
Logged

LEDs need to stop taking over everything
Administrator
Need help with something on the site? Let me know!

Print 
© 2005-2026 Lighting-Gallery.net | SMF 2.0.19 | SMF © 2021, Simple Machines | Terms and Policies